I have gotten copies of other reviews but only anonymously.


At 08:45 AM 12/20/2005, you wrote:
>Quick question:
>
>When you review papers for journals, do you ever get a copy of the other 
>reviewer(s) review? Do you have any thoughts on the rights and wrongs of this?
>
>I raise this issue as the Journal of Bus. Ethics has a file management 
>system and I didn't realise that it allows reviewers access to the other 
>review and they are also sent it when the resubmit goes out. I hadn't 
>realised this happened and had one reviewer really angry about it. The 
>person at Springer was surprised by my request to change this. So I said I 
>would ask around to see what others think. Comments?
>
>Sally

**********************************************************

Frank Cross
McCombs School of Business
The University of Texas at Austin
1 University Station B6000
Austin, TX 78712-1178